
An educational guide for accountants and solicitors on conflicts of interest, professional independence and choosing financial planning partners whose practices align with their own ethical standards.
By Steve Conley, Chartered Financial Planner
Founder, Academy of Life Planning
The professional responsibility that doesn’t end with a referral
Imagine a solicitor recommending a particular accountant to a client.
The accountant offers a tax planning service, but the business model only works if the client subsequently purchases another service from the same firm.
The initial planning work is presented as independent professional judgement, yet the firm’s income depends on the client proceeding with the subsequent transaction.
Would the solicitor want to know?
Would they ask whether the accountant was free to recommend doing nothing? Whether the client could purchase the planning service without agreeing to anything else? Whether the accountant’s remuneration created a conflict of interest?
Of course. These are fundamental questions of professional integrity.
Now consider what happens when an accountant or solicitor refers a client to a financial planner.
Does the same scrutiny apply?
It should.
Because referring a client to another professional is not merely an introduction. It is an exercise of professional judgement, and it carries the weight of the referring professional’s reputation.
1. What do professional codes actually require?
The professional obligations of accountants and solicitors are not identical, but they share a common ethical foundation.
Solicitors: independence, integrity and the client’s best interests
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) Principles require solicitors to act with independence, integrity and in the best interests of each client.
These are not simply aspirational values. They underpin enforceable professional obligations. Solicitors Regulation Authority+1
Paragraph 5.1 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors specifically addresses referrals, introductions and fee-sharing arrangements.
It requires transparency about financial or other interests in referrals, disclosure of relevant fee-sharing arrangements and written fee-sharing agreements.
The Code also prohibits acting where an own-interest conflict, or a significant risk of one, arises. Disclosure alone does not automatically cure such a conflict. Solicitors Regulation Authority+1
This establishes an important starting point.
FCA authorisation is not a universal professional licence
A solicitor cannot assume that a referral is professionally appropriate simply because the receiving firm is FCA-authorised.
There is a more fundamental question: authorised to do what?
FCA authorisation is specific to the regulated activities for which a firm holds permission. The Financial Services Register identifies those permissions, together with applicable limitations, requirements and other relevant regulatory information.
A firm authorised to advise on investments does not thereby obtain authorisation for every financial service it might offer.
Nor does FCA authorisation constitute an endorsement of all its activities, professional competencies or commercial practices.
Before referring a client, a solicitor should therefore distinguish:
- The service being referred: What does the client actually need?
- The regulatory status of that service: Is it a regulated activity, and if so, under which regulatory regime?
- The provider’s permissions: Does the receiving firm hold the appropriate permissions, where required?
- Professional competence: Is the practitioner suitably qualified, experienced and insured for that particular work?
- Commercial independence: Are there incentives or dependencies that could compromise the client’s interests?
The FCA itself advises consumers to check that a financial firm has the correct permissions for the products or services being offered.
The same verification is an important component of a professionally responsible referral.
For example, a referral for generic retirement planning is not necessarily a referral for regulated investment advice. Equally, a referral for a personal recommendation concerning a particular regulated investment cannot simply be treated as generic financial planning to avoid the applicable requirements.
A firm may legitimately undertake both activities, but its FCA authorisation applies to activities within the scope of its relevant permissions.
This distinction matters for another reason: the availability of regulatory protections may depend on the particular activity and circumstances, not merely on the firm’s authorised status.
Accountants and solicitors should not confuse the regulatory status of a business with the regulatory status of everything that business does.
A professional referral requires understanding the difference.
The suitability of the referral, the client’s interests and the solicitor’s own responsibilities remain relevant.
Accountants: integrity, objectivity and professional competence
The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW) Code of Ethics, updated from 1 July 2026, is based on five fundamental principles:
- Integrity
- Objectivity
- Professional competence and due care
- Confidentiality
- Professional behaviour
The Code requires accountants to identify, evaluate and address threats to these principles.
A particularly relevant threat is self-interest: when a financial or other interest risks improperly influencing professional judgement. ICAEW+1
The Code also addresses referral fees, commissions and agency arrangements.
Section 331 recognises that recommending or referring a client to another service provider can create ethical threats. It requires attention to whether the third party is suitable, not merely whether an introduction is commercially advantageous. ICAEW+1
The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) follows comparable fundamental ethical principles, including objectivity and avoiding compromised professional judgement through conflicts or undue influence. ACCA Global
For both professions, a central question emerges:
If you would not accept a particular conflict of interest in your own professional practice, why would you overlook that conflict when choosing someone to whom you refer your client?
2. Financial planning and investment intermediation are not the same activity
This distinction is critical, yet often misunderstood.
Financial planning can involve understanding a person’s circumstances, establishing objectives, assessing resources, exploring options and developing a practical plan for their future.
It might encompass retirement, employment, family responsibilities, housing, tax considerations, business ownership, succession, financial security and the development of human capital.
Many of these activities do not require the sale or purchase of an investment product.
The FCA itself recognises this distinction.
In its Perimeter Guidance, PERG 8.26.2, it identifies financial planning as an example of generic advice that does not fall within the regulated activity of advising on investments under Article 53(1).
However, the regulatory classification depends on what is actually done. A particular investment recommendation or another regulated activity may bring relevant parts of the service within the regulatory perimeter. FCA Handbook+1
Therefore, financial planning and regulated investment advice can be delivered together, but they are not synonymous.
A financial planning practitioner may be qualified, experienced, professionally insured and accountable to a professional code without being authorised to recommend particular regulated investments.
Equally, an FCA-authorised financial adviser may offer excellent financial planning alongside regulated investment recommendations.
The important question is what service is being provided, how it is delivered and how the provider is remunerated.
FCA authorisation demonstrates permission to undertake specified regulated activities. It does not, by itself, establish that a firm’s financial planning is commercially independent of investment intermediation.
Nor does membership of a professional body automatically establish competence or insurance for every service someone offers.
Those matters deserve separate verification.
3. Two meanings of independence that should never be confused
The FCA distinguishes between independent and restricted investment advice.
These descriptions concern the nature and scope of regulated investment advice, including the range of investments considered and relevant relationships affecting recommendations.
A firm offering independent investment advice may nevertheless generate substantial revenue from implementing and servicing investments. COBS 6.2B Describing advice services+1
That is not a contradiction under the FCA’s rules.
But independence of investment recommendations is different from independence of the financial planning service itself.
Consider two possible models.
Model A
Standalone planning
The client pays for planning as a complete service.
The plan can recommend action, inaction or specialist support.
The client can take the completed plan elsewhere.
Model B
Intermediation-linked planning
Planning is commercially connected to investment advice or implementation.
Revenue may depend materially on assets advised upon or serviced.
The economics may favour retaining an investment relationship.
Illustrative business models, not a legal classification. Real firms may combine features of both.
Neither model automatically determines whether the practitioner is ethical, competent or compliant.
However, they create different economic incentives.
A standalone planner can earn a fee even when the best outcome is for the client to make no investment transaction.
An intermediation-linked firm can also recommend no transaction, but doing so may be less commercially rewarding.
That difference matters.
An accountant or solicitor evaluating a potential referral partner should understand whether investment intermediation is an optional specialist service or an economic dependency of the planning proposition.
4. The conflict that can remain even when nobody receives a referral fee
Professional referrers are familiar with direct financial conflicts.
Suppose an accountant receives £500 for introducing a client to a financial adviser.
The potential conflict is obvious. There is a financial incentive to recommend that adviser.
The professional codes contain specific safeguards and disclosure obligations for such arrangements. ICAEW has, for example, emphasised the importance of obtaining proper client consent to commissions and referral fees. ICAEW
But consider a different scenario.
The accountant receives no referral fee.
The solicitor receives no referral fee.
The financial advisory firm earns revenue by providing investment advice and managing or servicing client investments, with charges based partly on the assets involved.
The referring professional may have no personal financial conflict.
Yet the receiving firm may have a commercial incentive to recommend maintaining assets within an ongoing paid relationship.
This is a different issue.
It does not establish misconduct or necessarily create a prohibited conflict. FCA rules expressly regulate adviser charging, incentives, disclosures and conduct within such models. FCA+1
Nevertheless, it raises a legitimate professional due-diligence question:
Does the financial planner’s business model influence the range of solutions the client is likely to be offered?
The absence of a referral commission does not answer that question.
We might call this the downstream incentive problem.
The referring professional can have entirely proper motives, yet still introduce a client into a commercial arrangement whose incentives they have not examined.
That is why professional referral due diligence should extend beyond the immediate financial relationship between the two firms.
5. A practical example: the client who doesn’t need an investment product
Consider a 62-year-old client approaching retirement.
They have a pension, savings, a mortgage, a business interest and some concerns about providing financial support to their adult children.
Their accountant recommends financial planning.
The planner discovers that the client’s immediate priorities are to reduce expenditure, improve cash flow, clarify retirement choices, consider downsizing and establish appropriate legal arrangements with a solicitor.
The client does not need to purchase a new investment product.
In fact, their most valuable asset may be their remaining earning capacity, and their most valuable decision may be to continue working part-time doing something they enjoy.
Now consider what happens under different commercial arrangements.
In a standalone planning model, the planner can produce a plan, charge the agreed fee and complete the engagement.
In an investment-linked model, the firm may still deliver exactly the same outcome. A good adviser should be willing to do so.
But what if most of the firm’s income comes from percentage-based charges on investment assets?
What happens when the client’s most appropriate solution produces little or no investment revenue?
What happens when a client has £600,000 in investments but the best financial strategy is to pay down debt, fund a business, invest in professional development or make gifts to family members?
These are legitimate planning questions.
They are also questions about incentives.
The test of professional independence is not whether the planner can recommend a product. It is whether they can recommend no product, without their commercial interests compromising the judgement.
6. Eight questions accountants and solicitors should ask before making referrals
Professional due diligence need not be burdensome. However, it should examine the actual service rather than rely exclusively on professional titles or regulatory status.
Referral partner due-diligence checklist
Competence and accountability
What qualifications, experience, professional memberships, supervision and professional indemnity cover apply to the actual service?
The planning deliverable
Will the client receive a usable written plan that can be acted upon independently of the provider?
Commercial independence
Can the client purchase and complete financial planning without purchasing an investment product or entering an ongoing investment relationship?
Regulatory permissions and professional scope
Is the proposed service regulated, and if so, by whom? Where FCA authorisation is required, have you checked the firm’s current permissions, limitations and applicable requirements on the Financial Services Register? Have you verified that the individual practitioner has the relevant competence, professional standing and insurance for the work being referred?
Remember that FCA authorisation for one financial activity does not automatically cover another, and generic financial planning is not necessarily a regulated investment activity.
Remuneration
What will the client pay for planning, investment recommendations, implementation and ongoing services? How is each charge calculated?
Conflicts and incentives
What financial or commercial interests could influence the provider’s recommendations, and how are they identified, managed and disclosed?
Client control
Can the client take the plan elsewhere, use their existing providers, make their own arrangements or decide not to transact?
Professional collaboration
Will the planner recognise when legal, tax, accountancy or other specialist expertise is needed, and respect the client’s right to choose that specialist?
These questions do not establish a new regulatory test. They provide a practical framework through which a professional firm can assess the suitability of its referral relationships.
An especially revealing question is:
“If my client decides not to purchase, transfer or retain any investments through your firm, will they still receive the complete financial planning service they have paid for?”
The answer tells you something important about what the firm regards as its core service.
7. The professional distinction: recognising conflicts is not the same as eliminating every incentive
It would be unreasonable to argue that all commercial incentives are inherently unethical.
Accountants charge fees.
Solicitors charge fees.
Financial planners charge fees.
All professional practices need revenue to survive.
An hourly fee can create an incentive to undertake unnecessary work. A fixed fee can create an incentive to minimise work. An assets-under-advice fee can create an incentive to retain assets within an advisory relationship.
No remuneration model is automatically free of conflicts.
Professionalism is demonstrated by how those incentives are recognised, managed and subordinated to the client’s interests.
The FCA has rules governing investment adviser charges, including disclosure of charging structures and client-specific costs. Those arrangements should not be casually confused with traditional product-provider commissions, which are generally prohibited for regulated retail investment advice. FCA+2
The important point is not that asset-based charging proves inappropriate behaviour.
It is that the method of payment may influence incentives, and those incentives deserve examination.
Professional referrers should therefore distinguish three questions:
- Is the activity lawful and appropriately regulated?
- Is the practitioner competent and operating to recognised professional standards?
- Is the practitioner’s commercial model appropriate for this client’s needs, objectives and independence?
A positive answer to the first two does not automatically establish the third.
8. Choosing professionals whose ethics are consistent with your own
There is an opportunity here for a different kind of professional relationship.
Instead of treating financial planning referrals as introductions to firms that can manage a client’s investments, accountants and solicitors could build networks of professionals whose primary purpose is to help clients make informed decisions.
That does not exclude investment advisers.
Quite the opposite.
Where a client needs a recommendation about a particular regulated investment, a suitably authorised and competent specialist may be exactly the right person.
But the need for investment intermediation should follow from the client’s circumstances, not be presumed at the point of referral.
An independently delivered financial plan can identify where specialist services are required.
The client can then decide which specialists to engage.
This is familiar territory for accountants and solicitors.
A solicitor preparing an estate plan may recommend specialist tax advice without requiring the client to use a particular accountant.
An accountant may identify a need for legal advice without attempting to control which solicitor the client appoints.
Why should financial planning be different?
A professional network built around the client could work as follows:
The client
Owns the goals, choices and decisions
Independent financial planning
Clarity, options, priorities and an actionable plan
Legal
Tax and accounting
Investment
Specialist expertise is engaged when needed, with client choice preserved throughout.
The financial planner does not need to control the specialist relationships.
The accountant does not need to control the financial planner.
The solicitor does not need to control the accountant.
Each professional contributes expertise within their competence, while the client retains agency over the overall plan.
This is professional collaboration without commercial dependency between disciplines.
9. From referral networks to professional communities
There is a difference between a referral network and a professional community.
A referral network can be built around reciprocal introductions, commercial agreements and the movement of clients between firms.
A professional community is built around shared standards, complementary expertise and the client’s interests.
Neither mutual introductions nor commercial arrangements are automatically improper.
But when referral relationships become entrenched, it is worth asking whether they continue to serve the client or have become relationships that primarily serve the firms involved.
Accountants and solicitors already understand the importance of reviewing long-standing professional relationships.
The same discipline could be applied to financial planning referral arrangements.
ICAEW’s 2026 Code explicitly recognises that a duty of care may arise when an accountant makes a professional referral. ICAEW
That makes the quality of the professional relationship important.
Perhaps the most valuable financial planning partner is not the firm that promises to share revenue, retain assets or generate reciprocal introductions.
Perhaps it is the practitioner who is comfortable saying:
“This client doesn’t need an investment product. They need a better understanding of their choices.”
Or:
“The answer is legal, not financial. They should speak to their solicitor.”
Or simply:
“The client now understands their position and can make the decision themselves.”
That is professionalism measured by what the client gains, rather than what the intermediary earns.
10. The question every professional referrer should be able to answer
Before making a financial planning referral, an accountant or solicitor should be comfortable explaining why the professional is suitable.
Not merely that the firm is FCA-authorised.
Not merely that its advisers hold professional qualifications.
Not merely that the referring firm has worked with it for years.
But that its competence, service, incentives and ethical standards are appropriate to the client’s needs.
And where the financial planning service is commercially linked to investment intermediation, the professional should understand that relationship well enough to explain its potential implications.
The codes governing accountants and solicitors do not impose a universal requirement to use standalone financial planners. Nor does the presence of a commercial dependency automatically prove a breach of either profession’s code.
But the principles of independence, integrity, objectivity and professional competence provide a compelling reason to examine how the receiving firm actually operates.
This is ultimately a question about professional consistency.
If independence matters when you provide professional services, shouldn’t it matter when you recommend someone else’s?
The next time you refer a client for financial planning, ask yourself:
Am I referring my client to someone who will help them make their own financial decisions, or to a business whose income depends on what the client does next?
The answer may be both.
What matters is that you know the difference.
Professional references
The principal sources for this educational article are:
- SRA Principles — independence, integrity and clients’ best interests.
- SRA Code of Conduct — particularly sections 5.1–5.3 and 6.1–6.2.
- ICAEW Code of Ethics 2026 — fundamental principles, fees, remuneration and referrals.
- ACCA Code of Ethics and Conduct — integrity, objectivity and professional behaviour.
- FCA PERG 8.26 — generic financial planning and regulated investment advice.
- FCA Adviser Charging Rules — remuneration and disclosure requirements.
This article provides general professional education, not a legal determination of any particular referral arrangement. Practitioners should consider their own professional body’s rules, applicable legislation, insurance arrangements and the individual circumstances of the client.
Case study: When the client pays for the planning, not the product
Mushtaq Jaigirdar — Financial Planner and NHS Pension Scheme Specialist
What might an alternative referral relationship look like in practice?
Consider Mushtaq Jaigirdar, an experienced financial planning professional who specialises in helping doctors, dentists and other healthcare practitioners.
Mushtaq has almost 25 years’ experience in financial planning and particular expertise in the complexities of the NHS Pension Scheme.
He describes his approach on LinkedIn:
“As a Holistic Financial Planner I do not sell financial products but guide with financial planning strategies in order to achieve clear outcomes.”
This is a significant distinction.
Mushtaq’s professional proposition is not built around acquiring investment assets or securing product transactions.
It is built around helping clients understand their financial position and make better decisions.
In July 2026, the Academy of Life Planning published a detailed case study documenting his transition from traditional financial advice to standalone financial planning.
The commercial question was simple: would clients pay for financial planning if the planner was not selling them investment products?
His experience suggests that they will.
Over approximately two years, Mushtaq estimated that he had worked with close to 50 clients through a combination of defined projects and ongoing planning relationships.
Some clients needed help understanding NHS pension benefits. Others needed to evaluate retirement decisions, business arrangements, taxation or significant changes in their personal circumstances.
The client’s needs determined the work.
The availability of an investment transaction did not.
A GP who needed clarity, not an investment product
One example from the Academy case study involved a GP partner experiencing serious difficulties within a professional partnership.
The client was considering leaving, but needed to understand the financial and practical consequences.
The issues included income, NHS pension benefits, business development and the affordability of changing careers.
Mushtaq supported the client over approximately eighteen months.
No investment product was implemented during that period.
No portfolio needed to be transferred.
No assets needed to be gathered under management.
Nevertheless, the client received valuable professional support in reaching a major life decision.
The GP eventually left the partnership and concentrated on developing a new business.
The financial planning had value because it improved the client’s ability to make a decision, not because it generated an investment transaction.
Why this matters to accountants and solicitors
This approach creates opportunities for productive professional collaboration.
An accountant supporting a dental practice might recognise that the partners need help understanding their NHS pension entitlements or evaluating retirement options.
A solicitor advising on business succession, estate planning or a family matter might identify a need for wider financial planning.
In either situation, the professional can introduce the client to a planning specialist whose work is not dependent on the client purchasing an investment product.
The accountant retains responsibility for the accountancy and tax matters within their competence.
The solicitor remains responsible for the legal matters.
The financial planner helps the client understand the wider financial implications, assess options and make informed decisions.
Where regulated investment recommendations or specialist implementation become necessary, appropriately authorised professionals can be engaged.
There is no requirement for the planner to control every part of the client’s financial life.
In Mushtaq’s model, professional success is measured increasingly by the client’s education, clarity, confidence and ability to act.
That is an interesting proposition for accountants and solicitors.
After all, the best professional service is not necessarily the one that creates the longest commercial relationship.
It may be the one that leaves the client better equipped to manage their own affairs.
The client pays for professional capability, not for permanent dependency.
Source: Academy of Life Planning, “Planner Story No. 1: The Financial Adviser Who Discovered Clients Would Pay to Become More Capable”, 22 July 2026.

Q: Is a well-known financial services brand enough to justify a professional referral?
A: A financial planning firm may be large, long-established, nationally recognised and FCA-authorised.
But does that make it an appropriate referral partner?
Not necessarily.
Professional reputation and regulatory authorisation are relevant considerations. Neither replaces the need to understand whether the provider is suitable for the client’s particular requirements.
For accountants, ICAEW’s Code of Ethics expressly requires consideration of a third party’s fitness for purpose when making a referral.
For solicitors, the principles of independence, integrity and acting in clients’ best interests provide the foundation for evaluating referral arrangements.
This matters because professional due diligence may itself become the subject of regulatory scrutiny.
Imagine an auditor asking why your practice routinely refers clients to a particular wealth management firm.
Would your answer be that the firm is large, established and well known?
Or could you demonstrate that you considered its professional competence, relevant regulatory permissions, service proposition, remuneration arrangements and suitability for the clients concerned?
A failure to undertake appropriate due diligence could result in compliance findings, remedial requirements or, where the circumstances justify it, professional disciplinary consequences.
If clients subsequently suffer harm, questions may also arise about the referring professional’s responsibility, although liability is not automatic.
The point is not that large financial services businesses are unsuitable referral partners.
It is that professional judgement cannot be outsourced to a brand.
Your professional reputation is built on the quality of your judgement.
That includes the judgement you exercise about whom to recommend to your clients.