
Financial planning. Independence. Taking control. Three attractive promises. But what do they actually mean when the service being sold depends on financial intermediation?
By Steve Conley, Founder, Academy of Life Planning
Words matter. Especially when money is involved.
Imagine seeing an advertisement that says:
“Want to take control of your future? Talk to a financial advisor to map out your financial life in full detail and make plans accordingly.”
It sounds perfectly reasonable.
Who wouldn’t want to take control of their future? Who wouldn’t benefit from mapping out their finances and developing a plan?
But there’s an assumption buried in that invitation.
Why does taking control of your financial future require you to engage a financial intermediary?
You can map out your financial life yourself. You can understand your income, expenditure, assets, liabilities, pensions, aspirations and obligations. You can explore alternatives, make decisions and develop a plan.
You might benefit from education, technology or occasional specialist assistance.
But none of that necessarily requires someone else to recommend investments or manage your money.
The advertisement introduces a professional intermediary as the natural route to something the consumer might be perfectly capable of doing independently.
And that raises a wider concern.
Are financial services firms selling consumers what their words promise, or what their business models require?
Take control. By handing it over?
There’s a difference between taking control of your finances and employing someone to take responsibility for aspects of them.
Both can be legitimate choices.
Some people prefer to delegate. They may value convenience, professional judgement, ongoing monitoring or the reassurance of having someone else involved.
Nothing wrong with that.
But delegation and empowerment are not the same service.
If an adviser helps you understand your choices, develop the confidence to make decisions and act independently, your capability has increased.
If an adviser instead makes recommendations you are unable to evaluate and manages arrangements you don’t understand, you may feel reassured without becoming more capable.
That doesn’t necessarily make the service poor. It does make the distinction important.
Feeling in control because someone else is looking after things is not the same as being in control yourself.
Consumers deserve to know which outcome they’re buying.
Independent. But independent of what?
Another advertisement suggests that consumers are better served by independent financial advisers than restricted advisers.
There is a genuine regulatory distinction.
Independent investment advice must meet requirements concerning the range of products considered and the absence of certain restrictions. Restricted advice operates within disclosed limitations.
But regulatory independence does not necessarily mean independence from the commercial arrangements of the firm employing or supervising the adviser.
Many advisory firms operate Centralised Investment Propositions, commonly called CIPs.
These may prescribe or strongly favour particular investment approaches, model portfolios, platforms or fund ranges.
Centralisation can bring benefits. It can improve consistency, governance, oversight and operational efficiency.
But it also creates questions.
What happens when an individual client’s needs are better met by a solution outside the firm’s preferred investment arrangements?
Can the adviser recommend it?
What additional permissions, research or compliance approvals are required?
And how often does that happen?
The FCA has explicitly warned firms against shoehorning clients into centralised investment propositions.
So independence deserves a more searching examination than simply checking whether an adviser is labelled independent or restricted.
There is regulatory independence.
There is commercial independence.
And there is independence from the need to generate revenue through investment intermediation.
These are not the same thing.
An adviser may meet the regulatory definition of independence while working within a business model that depends on customers purchasing ongoing investment-related services.
That is not necessarily a regulatory failing.
But it is something consumers should understand.
Financial planning. Or investment intermediation?
This is where the language becomes particularly interesting.
The financial services industry routinely uses the term financial planning to describe its activities.
Yet financial planning and regulated investment advice are not synonymous.
The FCA’s own Perimeter Guidance, PERG 8.26.2, explicitly identifies financial planning as an example of generic advice that may fall outside the regulated activity of advising on particular investments.
Financial planning does not inherently require the recommendation of an investment product.
It begins with the person.
What are they trying to achieve? What resources do they have? What obligations must they meet? What choices are available? What risks could disrupt their plans?
Those questions can encompass employment, education, housing, family relationships, health, pensions, taxation, debt, business ownership, care, inheritance and much more.
Investments might be part of the solution.
They are not the definition of the problem.
Yet many financial planning propositions are delivered through businesses whose revenue depends substantially on investment advice, investment management or related services.
This raises an obvious question.
Is financial planning the product being sold, or is financial planning the process through which the firm acquires and retains investment clients?
The answer will differ between firms.
Some provide genuinely comprehensive, separately identifiable financial planning.
Others provide planning primarily as part of an ongoing investment advice relationship.
The distinction matters.
The interactive investor example
Consider ii Advice, the financial advice proposition offered by interactive investor within the Aberdeen group.
The service advertises a personalised financial roadmap, investment recommendations and ongoing support.
Its published ongoing advice fee for an individual is £100 per month.
That’s £1,200 a year before relevant investment charges.
The investment recommendations are restricted to Aberdeen’s MyFolio fund range, held through Aberdeen’s Wrap platform.
And ii explicitly identifies people seeking one-off advice or wishing to implement recommendations themselves as customers for whom the service is not suitable.
Now, none of this establishes that ii is doing anything improper.
It discloses that the advice is restricted. It identifies its charging structure and the investment arrangements involved.
It may provide valuable financial planning, professional judgement and ongoing support to customers who want those services.
But look at the structure.
A customer who wants help mapping out their financial future, considering retirement options and developing an investment strategy cannot simply purchase the roadmap on a standalone basis under this proposition and then walk away to implement their preferred solutions independently.
The planning service is packaged with an ongoing advice and investment-management relationship.
The customer isn’t simply buying a plan.
They’re buying access to planning through a particular commercial model.
And that changes the question we should be asking.
Not merely: Is £100 a month competitive with other financial advisers?
But:
Why must a customer who wants a financial plan also purchase an ongoing intermediary relationship?
For some people, the combined service will be worth paying for.
For others, the planning itself may be what they want.
Why shouldn’t they be able to buy that separately?
The economics of dependence
Imagine two people approaching retirement.
Both have £200,000 in investments.
Both want to understand their pensions, future expenditure, retirement income, tax position and investment choices.
The first employs an adviser who develops a financial plan, recommends investments and provides ongoing monitoring.
The second uses educational resources, AI-assisted financial modelling and a low-cost investment platform. They obtain specialist professional assistance when their circumstances require it.
Both approaches have risks and limitations.
AI can make mistakes. Tax and pension rules are complex. Some circumstances require specialist judgement, and regulated advice can provide protections and accountability that self-directed tools cannot replicate.
But the second person does not automatically require an ongoing financial intermediary to achieve their planning objectives.
That possibility changes the economic comparison.
The first customer might pay £1,200 annually for ongoing advice, in addition to relevant investment charges.
Over ten years, assuming the fee remains unchanged, that’s £12,000 in nominal advice fees.
The important question is what additional value the ongoing service delivers.
Does it improve decisions? Prevent costly mistakes? Reduce unnecessary risks? Save time? Provide valuable accountability?
Those benefits may be real.
But they should be identifiable rather than presumed.
And customers should be able to ask whether they could obtain the planning benefits without purchasing the entire package.
The alternative to an expensive adviser is not necessarily a cheaper adviser. It may be no ongoing adviser at all.
What changes when AI enters the picture?
For decades, much of the financial services industry’s value has rested on information and expertise that ordinary consumers found difficult or expensive to access.
Understanding pensions, modelling retirement income, comparing investment costs and exploring financial scenarios often required substantial professional assistance.
AI changes the accessibility of many of these activities.
A person can now ask an AI assistant to explain pension options, model cash flows, challenge assumptions, compare possible strategies and identify questions requiring specialist attention.
The results still need verification. AI is not a substitute for every form of professional expertise, and it cannot automatically provide the same legal and regulatory protections as an authorised professional.
But it can help people become far better informed before they decide whether professional intervention is necessary.
And that undermines an important commercial assumption.
The fact that somebody needs help understanding their finances does not mean they need somebody to manage their investments.
A need for understanding is not automatically a need for intermediation.
Nor does every need for professional judgement justify a permanent professional relationship.
Sometimes the customer needs an explanation.
Sometimes they need a plan.
Sometimes they need a specialist.
And sometimes they genuinely want to delegate.
These are four different needs. They should not automatically result in the same commercial solution.
The financial services language gap
Three familiar promises now deserve closer scrutiny.
Take control.
Does the service increase the customer’s capability to understand and act, or primarily provide somebody else to take decisions and manage arrangements?
Independent.
Is the provider independent of commercial interests and investment intermediation, or independent only within the meaning of a particular regulatory classification?
Financial planning.
Can the customer purchase a financial plan and implement it independently, or must they enter an ongoing investment relationship to access the planning service?
In each case, the words may be technically defensible.
But the service delivered may be narrower, more conditional or more commercially dependent than the language initially suggests.
This is what I mean by the financial services language gap.
The distance between what the language leads a consumer to expect and what the commercial proposition actually delivers.
And there’s a legal dimension worth considering.
Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, consumer protection law addresses misleading commercial practices, including circumstances where the overall presentation creates a deceptive impression.
That doesn’t mean these advertisements necessarily break the law.
We would need to examine the full advertisements, the services offered, the likely consumer interpretation and the relevant circumstances.
But it does mean the question of overall impression matters.
A technically accurate description is not necessarily the end of the inquiry.
A simple test for consumers
Before paying for financial planning, ask the provider:
“Can I pay you to help me develop a financial plan, take that plan away, and independently choose how, when and with whom to implement it?”
If the answer is yes, you have the option of purchasing financial planning as a standalone service.
If the answer is no, ask why.
Perhaps the firm offers an integrated service because it believes ongoing implementation, monitoring and professional responsibility produce better outcomes.
That may be a perfectly reasonable business choice.
But it should be described as such.
The consumer should understand that they’re purchasing an integrated financial advice and investment proposition, not simply obtaining a financial plan.
And there is one further question:
“If I decide not to invest through your firm, what exactly can you still do for me?”
The answer reveals a great deal about the nature of the relationship.
Planning should not require dependency
At the Academy of Life Planning, we take a different approach.
We start with the individual’s life, not their investment portfolio.
We help people understand their circumstances, recognise their choices, develop plans and strengthen their ability to act.
We use education, practical frameworks, AI and human support.
Where specialist expertise is required, people can engage the appropriate professional.
They remain free to choose whether to implement solutions themselves, seek further assistance or delegate particular responsibilities.
Our objective is not to make financial intermediaries unnecessary in every situation.
It is to make unnecessary dependence on financial intermediaries avoidable.
That distinction matters.
A person who chooses to delegate after understanding their options is exercising agency.
A person who believes they must delegate because nobody has shown them another route may never have had a meaningful choice.
Independent financial planning should mean that the plan belongs to the person, not to the business model of the provider.
Perhaps it’s time to ask a different question
I’m not suggesting that every financial adviser misuses these terms.
Nor am I suggesting that professional advice, standardised investment solutions or ongoing management relationships are inherently inappropriate.
The issue is transparency.
Consumers should be able to distinguish planning from product recommendation, independence from commercial constraint, and personal control from professional delegation.
They should understand what they can do themselves, what support they can purchase separately, and what requires a continuing commercial relationship.
Most importantly, they should not have to buy investment intermediation merely because they want help making sense of their financial lives.
Financial planning is too important to be treated as an accessory to investment distribution.
And as AI makes information, analysis and practical planning increasingly accessible, the distinction will become harder to ignore.
The financial services industry has spent decades explaining its products to consumers. Perhaps it’s time consumers started asking the industry to explain its language.
Sources and regulatory references
- FCA Handbook, PERG 8.26 — Generic advice and financial planning.
- FCA, Assessing Suitability — Centralised investment propositions and avoiding unsuitable recommendations.
- FCA Handbook, COBS 6.2B — Independent and restricted advice descriptions.
- ii Advice — Published service, charging and investment arrangements.
- CMA, Unfair Commercial Practices — Misleading actions, omissions and overall presentation.
The advertisements discussed illustrate questions about marketing language, rather than findings of misconduct. Whether particular claims are misleading depends on their full context and the applicable legal tests.
