What Did the FCA Do With Ian Davis’s Evidence?

Get SAFE · By Steve Conley, founder of the Academy of Life Planning · 20 November 2026

When you send evidence to a regulator, what would reassure you that someone has looked at it?

An acknowledgement tells you it arrived. A case number tells you it was logged. The question Ian Davis’s story leaves us with is what happened after that.

Ian lost his life savings in the collapse of London Capital & Finance (LCF). He spent years gathering evidence and sending his findings to authorities, including the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). As a volunteer with the Transparency Task Force, he wanted other investors to be better protected. Ian died by suicide in March 2023, aged 61. An Early Day Motion tabled that month and signed by 33 MPs recognised his work and called for the agencies charged with tackling fraud to be held to account. UK Parliament’s Early Day Motion 963

What has changed this week?

On 18 November, The Banker reported that Transparency Task Force founder Andy Agathangelou had written to the FCA’s chair and chief executive asking for an independent inquiry into how the regulator handled Ian’s case. I support that request. I have yet to see a public announcement from the FCA confirming that it has commissioned an inquiry. The Banker’s report

Two days earlier, the Serious Fraud Office announced charges against eight people in connection with LCF’s collapse. They are due to appear at Westminster Magistrates’ Court on 7 December. The criminal allegations are for the courts to determine. The question for an independent inquiry is how the FCA responded when Ian brought it evidence and asked for help. Serious Fraud Office announcement

Dame Elizabeth Gloster’s independent review found that the FCA had failed to discharge its functions effectively in relation to LCF during the period it examined. Its remit ran up to 30 January 2019, the day administrators were appointed. The new request focuses on what happened when Ian sought answers after the collapse. The Gloster report and its terms of reference

Follow the evidence through the FCA

In December 2025, I wrote about an internal FCA email disclosed through a data subject access request. It showed that an individual’s emails had been filed with no further action despite a request for a response. That gives a reviewer a concrete question to test in Ian’s case. If his correspondence was diverted or subject to special handling, how did the FCA make sure new evidence still reached someone who could assess it? When Emails Are Diverted, People Are Disappeared

An independent reviewer should be able to trace Ian’s submissions from receipt to decision and answer four questions.

  1. What did the FCA receive, and when? What records survive of Ian’s submissions and requests for help?
  2. Who assessed the evidence? What decisions did they make, what reasons did they record, and how did they handle new material?
  3. What happened at each handover? If the FCA referred Ian or his evidence elsewhere, who accepted responsibility, and did anyone check what happened next?
  4. What did Ian hear back? Was he told what had been considered, what action the FCA could take and where he could turn for an answer?

People can be sent from one institution to another even when each office follows its own procedure. From the person’s side of the desk, every referral can mean starting again. In May, I wrote about the toll that unanswered correspondence, contradictory explanations and years of uncertainty can take after a financial loss. People need help while the system is deciding what to do. When Justice Arrives Too Late

What should change for the next person?

At the March APPG summit on investment fraud and fairer financial services, one speaker described a familiar cycle of scandal, inquiry, recommendations and inaction. An inquiry into Ian’s case should have an external chair, published terms of reference and access to the relevant records. Its findings should be published with due care for his family’s privacy. If it recommends changes, the public should be able to see who is responsible for each one, when it is due and whether it happened. The System Is Speaking. Are We Listening?

One practical change would be to make referrals traceable. When an authority passes evidence to another body, the person who submitted it should know where it went, who is responsible for the next step and whom to contact if they hear nothing. The authorities can confirm those details without disclosing confidential investigative work.

At Get SAFE, we help people regain enough stability to think clearly, organise their evidence and decide what to do next. That work has taught me how much effort it can take just to get a clear question in front of the right person. Once someone has brought evidence forward, the institutions have a responsibility to make sure it reaches someone who can assess it.

Ian did the work of bringing the evidence to the authorities. Can they show his family and the public what they did with it?

Read my tribute to Ian Davis and his work as a citizen investigator.

If you need someone to talk to, you can call Samaritans free on 116 123, day or night.

Leave a Reply