Leave the verdict to the court

Get SAFE · A practical guide for citizen investigators

You’ve spent months asking for an explanation. Then you find two versions of the same document. The wording has changed, and the institution’s decision may depend on which version it used. You open a new email and type, “This was a fraud. Someone needs to answer for this criminal conduct.”

Stop there. The most important thing you’ve found is the difference between those two documents. Put it in the first paragraph.

In ordinary dispute correspondence, do not accuse anyone of committing a crime unless a court has already made that finding about the conduct you’re writing about. If it has, cite the decision and say exactly what the court decided.

Read for meaning as well as wording. “Criminal”, “fraud”, “scam”, “forgery”, “theft”, “corruption” and “malfeasance” can all convey an accusation in context. So can “they cooked the books” or “they all knew and agreed to cover it up”. A question such as “How long have you been running this scam?” carries the accusation inside it.

An accusation gives them something to deny

An institution can reply, “We reject your allegations,” without explaining which document it relied on. You’ve then got a denial on file, and the question that prompted your letter is still unanswered.

Say you asked an insurer for arbitration. Its refusal email enclosed a booklet printed after the incident date recorded on your claim form. An earlier booklet has a different arbitration clause. The documents give you a precise question:

Your refusal email enclosed the later booklet. The earlier booklet I hold contains a different arbitration clause. I have set out the two clauses below. Please identify the policy schedule and clause that governed my request, and explain which wording you relied on when refusing arbitration. If different terms applied, please review your decision.

The two booklets can show that the wording changed. The schedule and any amendments can help establish which terms applied. The refusal email and the insurer’s records can help establish which wording it relied on. Each document has a job to do.

The same discipline applies when a record is missing. “I have yet to receive a copy of the order” describes your position. “The order does not exist” makes a claim about records you may never have seen. Ask for the official record, when it was made and how it was communicated to you.

Filter every draft before you send it

Anger makes sense when your money, livelihood or access to justice is at stake. Keep the impact in the letter. Say what the decision cost you, what you have already tried and what you want the recipient to do. Give the evidence the first word.

Paste the prompt below into ChatGPT, then add your draft and only the excerpts needed to check it. Remove personal identifiers, account details and confidential material before pasting. Use the revised letter as a draft and check every date, quote and reference against the original.

Copy-and-paste ChatGPT prompt

Review the draft below as an evidence editor for a citizen investigator. This is ordinary institutional dispute correspondence. My aim is to get an answer to the evidence and a clear response to my request.
1. Check the entire draft, including the subject line, headings and questions, for any accusation of criminal conduct, whether explicit or implied. Look for words such as criminal, fraud, scam, malfeasance, forgery, theft, corruption and conspiracy. Interpret them in context. Also flag phrases such as “cooked the books”, assertions about what people knew or intended, and questions that assume a crime took place. Do not simply add “I believe”, “alleged” or a question mark.
2. Leave accusations of criminal conduct out of the revised letter unless I supply a court decision that actually makes the relevant finding about the same person or organisation and the same conduct. If supplied, attribute the finding accurately to the court and give the citation. Treat a complaint, investigation, arrest, charge or a party’s allegation as what it is. Never turn any of these into a court finding or a conviction.
3. For each flagged passage, identify what I directly observed, what the supplied record actually says, and what remains uncertain. Attribute other people’s statements to their source. Treat a record I have not received as a record I have not received. Never infer from that alone that it does not exist.
4. Rewrite each point using the strongest available evidence. Put conflicting documents or statements side by side, with dates and references where supplied. Ask the recipient to identify the record they relied on, explain the discrepancy or review the decision. If evidence is missing, use a clear placeholder or ask for the missing record. Do not invent facts, quotations, intent, deadlines or legal requirements.
5. Preserve the impact on me, the remedy I am asking for and any material dates or procedural requests. If the draft appears to be a formal legal document or official report where removing an allegation could change its purpose, flag that for my review before rewriting it.
Return three things:
- The exact phrases you flagged and why.
- A complete revised subject line and letter in clear, firm language.
- Any quotes, dates, claims or references I need to check before sending.
Recipient and purpose:
[Insert here]
Relevant evidence or excerpts:
[Insert here]
My draft:
[Paste here]

Use this filter for ordinary dispute letters and emails. If you’re making an official report of a suspected crime, describe your suspicion and give the reporting body the facts that gave rise to it. You can report a suspicion before a court has considered it. If you’re preparing formal court papers and an allegation forms part of your case, get legal advice before changing it. UK guidance on reporting suspected fraud

Before you press send, read your first paragraph as if you’re seeing the dispute for the first time. Can you tell which document matters, what needs explaining and who can answer? If so, you’ve given the recipient a question they can act on and created a record of exactly what you asked.

Leave a Reply