
By Steve Conley, founder of the Academy of Life Planning
Independent means “not influenced or controlled in any way by other people, events, or things”, according to the Cambridge Dictionary. In everyday life, we usually know which influence the word is meant to rule out. Cambridge Dictionary
An independent parliamentary candidate stands without representing a political party. Martin Bell stood as an independent and won Tatton in 1997. Voters could judge him knowing he would sit in Parliament without a party whip. Electoral Commission · UK Parliament
An independent tribunal decides a dispute separately from the parties before it. If you appeal a tax decision to the First-tier Tribunal, HMRC can defend its original decision and you can challenge it. The tribunal decides the case independently of HMRC. The body whose decision is being challenged has to make its case like any other party. GOV.UK
Walk into financial services, though, and the word starts doing a different job. An independent financial adviser. An independent review by the regulator. Each time, I want to ask the same question.
Independent of what exactly?
Independent financial advice
The Financial Conduct Authority gives independent investment advice a specific meaning. An adviser must assess a sufficiently broad and diverse range of relevant products and guard against bias arising from close links and other relationships. The rules on adviser charging generally require the firm to be paid through adviser charges for covered retail investment recommendations. Those are meaningful protections. FCA rules on describing advice services · FCA rules on adviser charging
Now imagine you ask an adviser whether you can afford to cut your working week to three days. The adviser may be free to consider a wide range of investments. But if the firm earns an ongoing percentage of the assets it looks after, it also has a financial interest in how much money stays invested through the firm. Using some of that money to buy yourself more time may be exactly what makes your plan work. It may also reduce the firm’s income. MoneyHelper on adviser fees
An adviser can handle that conflict conscientiously. Some charge a fixed fee for planning alone. The point is that the label independent adviser does not tell you how the firm gets paid, or whether its planning work is commercially separate from arranging investments and servicing them afterwards.
There is a simple question you can put to any firm. If I leave my investments where they are and buy nothing, what will I pay you for helping me make the decision?
An independent review of the FCA
The word comes up again in the case of Simon Andriesz, a whistleblower who died by suicide. The FCA announced what it called an independent review into how it dealt with him and handled his disclosures. Its remit includes whether the FCA met its whistleblowing responsibilities and followed its own procedures. FCA announcement · Reuters reporting
The FCA’s non-executive directors commissioned the review. Lea Paterson, one of those directors, leads it with support from external legal advisers. The terms of reference say she will address her report to the FCA’s non-executive directors. Published terms of reference
A non-executive director can bring independent judgement to the scrutiny of management. Board oversight is part of the job. But who commissioned the review, who leads it and who receives the findings? In each case, the answer takes us back to the FCA’s own board. When the question is how the regulator itself acted, I think the public is entitled to ask for an assessment led from outside the institution. Otherwise, however diligent the review, the FCA is still marking its own homework.
Independent financial planning
At the Academy of Life Planning, independent financial planning means planning that stands outside the FCA-regulated wealth management industry. Our planners are paid for the work of planning. They do not recommend specific investments, arrange products, manage portfolios or take a percentage of your assets. If you need regulated investment advice, you can choose an authorised adviser separately. Academy of Life Planning accreditation · FCA perimeter guidance
Go back to the person who wants to work three days a week. We can model the drop in income, work out what it would take to make the change sustainable and explore what they want those two days for. The best next step might be a conversation with their employer. The planning has earned its fee if it helps them make a decision they can live with, even if every investment stays exactly where it is.
That is what I mean when I say plan the person before the money. And if that is the work you want to do, the Academy of Life Planning is where you can train and become an accredited Total Wealth Planner. Explore Total Wealth Planner accreditation
When we say independent, we mean independent.
