The Emperor’s New Fees

True Potential’s 8% adviser payouts, Cinven’s possible exit and the question AI puts in the hands of investors.

Steve Conley | Academy of Life Planning | 16 November 2026

FCA asked about True Potential’s 8% IFA payouts at public meeting. Client said regulator had not taken ‘undisclosed conflicts of interest seriously’ after they raised concerns about being transferred to private equity-owned consolidator. Citywire 16 November 2026.

In Hans Christian Andersen’s The Emperor’s New Clothes, a little child says what everyone else has been too embarrassed to say. The emperor has nothing on. The crowd repeats it. The emperor suspects they’re right and carries on with the procession anyway. The chamberlains keep holding up the train. Andersen’s original tale, first published in 1837

In my version, Cinven is the emperor. The advisers selling their client books to True Potential are the entourage. AI is the child in the crowd. And the line I’d give the child is this.

“I paid £7,850 last year. What did I get for it?”

The deal that paid when clients moved

On 16 November, Citywire reported that a client had challenged the Financial Conduct Authority over True Potential’s old 8% adviser payouts. The client said they’d been advised to transfer their pension, the move was processed as non-advised, and the adviser received an incentive the client hadn’t been told about. The FCA’s written reply said firms must manage conflicts of interest and act in clients’ best interests. It gave no firm-specific update. Citywire’s report · FCA responses, questions 10 and 11

In a published case, the Financial Ombudsman recorded that an adviser received about £65,000, equal to 8% of the pension assets transferred. True Potential paid it, and the Ombudsman left the incentive issue for a separate complaint. Economically, my duck test is simple. If the client stays put, does the adviser still get paid? In that case the transfer triggered the payment. Whether a particular commission or inducement rule was breached depends on what happened and which rules applied. In a separate case, the Ombudsman found unsuitable advice had been given even though the firm treated the move as non-advised. Ombudsman decision on the £65,000 payment · Separate decision on the advice given

The offer had real pulling power. Money Marketing reported that 181 advisers joined through the 8% retirement deal in 2020 alone. Citywire reported in early 2024 that True Potential had paid IFAs £372 million under its 8% deals since 2022. The Ombudsman records that an FCA-ordered skilled-person review led to the withdrawal of the incentive. Money Marketing · Citywire’s investigation · Ombudsman decision

Two exits and one stream of fees

True Potential still advertises a retirement buyout. Its September 2026 brochure offers up to 12 times eligible annual advice fee income, with the fee used for valuation capped at 0.5% a year. Its Central Advice Team takes over servicing at retirement. A book producing £50,000 in eligible annual advice fees could therefore attract up to £600,000 under the advertised terms. That multiple prices the book. Payback depends on how much advice income survives the handover and on any platform and fund income the deal brings in or helps retain, after costs. True Potential adviser brochure, pages 21–23 · True Potential’s 2025 accounts

The retiring adviser sells the expected income from a book. Cinven, which invested in January 2022, may sell its stake in the business that earns fees across many such books. A co-investor explicitly cited recurring revenue and low asset churn as attractions. Bloomberg reported on 11 November that Cinven was exploring a sale. Its reasons remain unconfirmed. Cinven’s portfolio entry · Co-investor’s investment rationale · Sale reporting

One figure I’d watch is net inflows. They fell from £1.8 billion in 2024 to £700 million in 2025, while adjusted EBITDA rose from £246.3 million to £266.3 million. Most of the fall came from less new money coming in. True Potential linked that to changes in adviser recruitment and client onboarding following FCA feedback. I read that as a possible leading indicator for exit timing. Existing assets can keep earnings rising while new money slows. If cheaper direct alternatives also start pulling money out or forcing fees down, a buyer can mark down what it will pay well before those effects show up in earnings. The published figures don’t tell us how many customers switched to cheaper platforms or whether AI played a part. True Potential’s 2025 accounts

That helps explain why some advisers approaching retirement may see little reason to switch to a fee-for-planning practice. They can keep earning recurring fees while waiting to sell the book. If they expect those valuations to fall, they may bring the sale forward. That is the game of musical chairs beneath the procession. The seller wants a seat while a buyer still believes the fees will keep flowing.

What did I get for £7,850?

Take a £500,000 pension. Here is an illustration using True Potential’s published tiered platform charges, its 0.50% Central Advice fee and a 0.74% ongoing fund charge, as shown in its published Pictet Balanced factsheet. For the direct example I’ve used Vanguard’s self-managed pension with a LifeStrategy 60% Equity fund.

Annual chargeTrue Potential illustrationVanguard self-managed illustration
Advice£2,500£0
Platform£1,650£375
Fund£3,700£1,000
Total£7,850£1,375

The gap is £6,475 a year, or £3,975 even before the True Potential advice fee. These are different investment services and portfolios, with potentially different risks. The example excludes initial fees and transaction costs. The gap is a difference in what the customer pays. How much the firm retains depends on its costs and what it pays to others. True Potential fee schedule · True Potential fund factsheet · Vanguard pension charges · Vanguard fund charges

A higher investment charge creates a hurdle every year. S&P’s mid-2026 scorecard found that 95.4% of active sterling-denominated global equity funds lagged their index over ten years, before any separate advice fee. That evidence concerns a fund category, so a fair comparison for a particular pension still needs a suitable benchmark and comparable risk. S&P SPIVA scorecard

Show me the planning

True Potential promises a personalised financial plan. Its guide to the annual Investment Review describes checking whether the investments still suit the client’s circumstances and issuing an action plan aimed at investment goals. I haven’t seen a public example of the plan its Central Advice Team gives someone after taking over from a retiring adviser. True Potential’s advice service · True Potential’s guide to its Investment Review

“Are your investments still suitable?” is a legitimate question. “Could you afford to retire two years earlier if you worked part-time first?” asks for different work. You’d need to look at the person’s life, test the cash flow and help them decide what to do. That’s financial planning, and it can be priced in its own right. The investment service then has to justify its own recurring charge.

A fee can be disclosed and still be hard to evaluate. That’s the information asymmetry. AI can help the investor put the charges, the review and an alternative side by side. It can total the fees in pounds, show where a document gives no figure, and help the client ask the firm to explain what each charge bought. The client can check the figures against the original documents before deciding what the answers mean.

Andersen’s emperor keeps walking. In this procession, the people paying for it get a choice. If your adviser retired tomorrow and you had to opt in again, which services would you buy at today’s price?

Leave a Reply