By Steve Conley, Academy of Life Planning
“A watchdog that must keep its masters solvent cannot bite.”
Britain is often praised for having one of the most tightly regulated financial systems in the world. Yet, time and again — from PPI to car-finance commissions — we witness the same grim pattern: abuse, denial, exposure, compensation, and reform that changes nothing.
A recent piece by Meridian Legal Services, “How the FCA Let Mis-Selling Become a Business Model,” lays bare a truth many inside the system already know: the problem isn’t lack of rules — it’s lack of independence.
A Culture of Managed Harm
Our regulators have become performers in a theatre of oversight — skilled at managing the aftermath, not preventing the cause.
Each scandal follows the same script:
- A lucrative practice flourishes unchecked.
- Warnings surface but are diluted by “consultation.”
- Public outrage forces belated enforcement.
- Redress arrives years later, framed as “progress.”
This cycle doesn’t represent incompetence; it reflects structural dependence. The FCA and its predecessors were designed to collaborate with those they regulate — funded by them, reliant on their data, and embedded in their worldview. Oversight became partnership; partnership became paralysis.
Self-Regulation: The Fatal Contradiction
The seed was planted in 1986 with the notion of “self-regulation within a statutory framework.” On paper, it balanced innovation with control. In practice, it built a system that polishes mirrors instead of cleaning windows.
Each reform since — the FSA, then the FCA and PRA — has been reactive, born from scandal rather than foresight. We have built a regulatory architecture that looks formidable but acts only once the damage is done.
As Meridian puts it:
“Britain’s regulators do not prevent harm as much as they manage it after the fact.”
Dependence Breeds Restraint
The FCA’s “risk-based” approach sounds prudent — prioritising systemic threats — but it entrenches inequality. The biggest firms, deemed essential to financial stability, receive the gentlest treatment. Smaller firms are punished swiftly to preserve the illusion of control.
This is not corruption; it’s quiet interdependence. Regulators cannot truly challenge those who fund their existence. Every consultation is shaped by the need to maintain “market confidence,” as if moral courage might spook investors.
In this way, confidence — not justice — becomes the regulator’s hidden mandate. Britain regulates through hindsight, soothing markets rather than protecting citizens.
The Revolving Door of Consensus
When the same professionals circulate between the Treasury, regulators, and City institutions, they bring not just experience but ideology. The belief that “markets self-correct,” that “innovation must be protected,” that “confidence is stability.”
This is not oversight — it’s orthodoxy. Governance by consensus cannot stand against greed.
Even the Consumer Duty, launched in 2023 to promote “good outcomes,” was quickly repackaged as a compliance product — software, templates, tick-boxes. Ethics became a commodity. A rule meant to restore principle was turned into another tool of performance.
Deferred Justice Is Not Justice
From PPI to LIBOR, from mini-bonds to motor finance, the script remains unchanged.
Fines are absorbed as business costs. Compensation is funded by future profits. Victims wait years to be told their suffering was “unacceptable.”
This is not reform — it’s maintenance. The system corrects itself just enough to survive.
“A system capable of cleaning up a disaster is still a system that allowed the disaster to happen.”
The Real Currency: Confidence or Conscience?
Confidence may be the lubricant of finance, but conscience is the foundation of civilisation. The more regulators prioritise appearance over integrity, the more fragile both become.
If we truly wish to restore trust, oversight must evolve from managing confidence to empowering conscience. That requires new forms of independence — not just financial, but moral.
From Regulatory Dependence to Human Empowerment
At the Academy of Life Planning, we’ve seen this pattern from another angle. Financial advisers, trapped in the same compliance theatre, are taught to sell products rather than solve problems. Consumers are told they need “advice,” when what they really need is education, empowerment, and ethical choice.
That’s why our mission is clear:
Replace extraction with empowerment.
Through our models —
- Academy of Life Planning for Holistic Wealth Planners,
- Planning My Life for self-directed citizens,
- Financial Life Coach for ethical professionals, and
- Get SAFE for citizen investigators —
we’re building a framework that restores independence where it matters most: within the individual.
A New Kind of Oversight: Citizen-Led Transparency
Real reform will not emerge from another FCA consultation. It will come from citizens who refuse to be deceived — whistleblowers, journalists, planners, and victims working together with AI tools and open data to shine light where institutions fear exposure.
Transparency is not a threat to stability; it is its only source.
When enough people see clearly, mirrors lose their magic.
Conclusion: The Courage to Act
Britain’s financial system remains exquisitely regulated in form, chronically ineffective in practice.
But change is already underway — at the grassroots, among people willing to reclaim their moral autonomy.
The future of financial planning is not compliance; it’s consciousness.
Not regulation by consent, but empowerment by design.
That is how we move from oversight as theatre to oversight as truth —
and from dependence to dignity.
About Get SAFE
Get SAFE (Support After Financial Exploitation) was born from a simple truth: too many victims of financial abuse are left to suffer in silence.
We exist for people like Ian Davis—for the ones who did everything right, only to be failed by the systems they trusted. We know that behind every vanished pension, every ignored complaint, and every stonewalled letter is a person—frightened, exhausted, and too often alone.
Get SAFE offers more than sympathy. We offer structure, support, and solidarity.
We provide a voice where there’s been silence, and clarity where there’s been confusion.
We stand beside those who have been exploited, not just to help them recover—but to help them reclaim their story and rebuild their future.
Because financial justice is not a luxury.
It’s a human right.
If you or someone you know has been affected by financial exploitation, we are here.
You are not alone.
Learn more at: Get SAFE (Support After Financial Exploitation).
Academy of Life Planning 