A new study from Vanguard has revealed a quiet revolution underway in financial advice — and most advisers don’t even see it coming.
Almost half of clients surveyed said they would like to meet their financial adviser more than once a year. On the surface, this might look like a call for better service. In truth, it’s a symptom of a deeper disconnect between advisers and their clients — a sign that the traditional, industrial model of financial advice is breaking down.
1. The Economic Mismatch — Service vs. Price
The study found that only 29% of advisers meet their clients more than once a year, despite nearly half of clients wanting more contact. Why? Because the industrial advice model is designed for efficiency, not relationship.
Most advisers want to earn six-figure incomes while servicing hundreds of clients. The maths only works if each client receives a few hours of attention per year in exchange for thousands in fees. Meeting more often would halve the adviser’s yield unless they doubled their fees — an option that would alienate most clients.
The one-meeting-per-year model isn’t a reflection of what clients need; it’s a reflection of what the adviser’s business model can sustain. It’s an economic compromise disguised as professionalism.
2. The Perception Gap — “Value Added” vs. Reality
Vanguard’s research reports that 93.6% of clients believe their adviser has made a meaningful difference to their portfolio. Yet, the data tells a different story.
Over the past two decades, low-cost index investing has outperformed most actively managed portfolios net of fees. The typical investor could have achieved similar or better results by investing directly through a simple platform and avoiding intermediary charges altogether.
The “value added” that clients perceive is not financial alpha — it’s emotional reassurance. The adviser gives them confidence, a sense of structure, and a human voice during volatile markets. These are valuable human needs, but they are not evidence of superior investment management.
The industry sustains this illusion because it preserves the rationale for its existence. It keeps clients believing they need an intermediary to “beat the market,” when in reality, what they need is guidance on aligning money with life — not life with money.
3. The Goal Illusion — Working to Adviser-Defined Outcomes
The study reports that 78% of clients feel confident in reaching their long-term goals thanks to their adviser. That statistic sounds impressive until we ask a simple question: whose goals are they?
Traditional advisers rarely explore a client’s deeper purpose or life aspirations. Goals are typically defined in financial terms — retirement income targets, investment balances, or product milestones. These are adviser-friendly metrics that align with product sales, not human flourishing.
Clients work for 40 years toward adviser-defined “freedom days,” expecting happiness at the end of the rainbow. Many reach retirement comfortable but unfulfilled — their wealth intact but their meaning lost. They’ve achieved financial goals without ever discovering their true ones.
4. The Emotional Comfort Loop — Safety Without Meaning
Vanguard also found that 76% of clients credit their adviser with boosting their mental and emotional wellbeing. This, too, deserves deeper reflection.
Financial advisers have become modern-day therapists of security. They soothe anxiety, manage uncertainty, and promise peace of mind — but the comfort they deliver operates at the level of ego: safety, control, and predictability. There is little exploration of soul: purpose, contribution, and transformation.
Clients emerge reassured yet restless — financially insulated but spiritually unsatisfied. They’ve been sold comfort, not coherence.
5. The Generational Disconnect — Tech vs. Tradition
Perhaps the clearest warning sign lies in the intergenerational data. Only 28% of investors believe their children will continue using their adviser after their death. Meanwhile, over half want legacy planning conversations to begin much earlier in life — in their 40s and 50s, not their 60s.
Advisers cite “lack of interest” from heirs as the reason for disengagement. The truth is more uncomfortable: younger generations are tech-savvy, financially literate, and value self-direction. They no longer need gatekeepers to access markets or manage money.
AI, open banking, and low-cost digital platforms have ended the information asymmetry on which intermediation once depended. The children of today’s clients will inherit their parents’ assets — but not their dependency.
6. What Clients Are Really Asking For
When clients say they want to meet more often, they’re not asking for more quarterly reviews or fund updates. They’re asking for human connection. They want someone to talk to about life’s transitions — health, purpose, family, and meaning — not just asset allocations.
They’re asking to be seen as whole people, not portfolios. And that requires a very different kind of professional — one who integrates financial planning with life planning, wealth with wellbeing, and intellect with empathy.
7. The Future — From Industrial Advisers to Holistic Wealth Planners
The Vanguard study doesn’t just reveal a gap in client engagement; it exposes a paradigm shift. The industrial adviser model — built on efficiency, control, and extraction — is incompatible with a world moving toward empowerment, transparency, and authenticity.
The future belongs to Holistic Wealth Planners: professionals who start with life, not money; who facilitate meaning before measurement; who empower clients to become co-creators of their own financial wellbeing.
This is not the end of advice. It’s the end of the old story of advice — and the beginning of a new one, where guidance replaces sales, collaboration replaces control, and every client is empowered to live their own GAME Plan: Goals, Actions, Means, and Execution — aligned in harmony with life itself.
Closing Reflection
The Vanguard study was meant to highlight a service gap. In reality, it has illuminated a soul gap — between what clients truly need and what the industry is built to deliver. Closing that gap will require not more meetings, but more meaning.
Join the Movement
If you’ve worked with me or the Academy, your voice matters. Please share your experience — your story inspires others to find theirs.
Leave a Google Review
If you’re new here, let’s explore how we can help you build your own freedom-based future.
Book a Free Call
Contact: steve.conley@aolp.co.uk
Website: www.aolp.info
Follow: Steve Conley on LinkedIn
Academy of Life Planning 