The October Budget is shaping up to be one of the most consequential in recent memory. Chancellor Rachel Reeves faces a fiscal shortfall of up to £50 billion, and with manifesto promises ruling out hikes to income tax, national insurance, or VAT, her gaze has turned to the property market.
At the centre of discussion is a proposal that has long haunted Westminster: a so-called “mansion tax.” Successive governments have toyed with the idea and backed away, fearing its political toxicity. Yet with limited room to manoeuvre, Reeves appears ready to consider what her predecessors avoided.
The Proposal: Ending Private Residence Relief
Currently, homeowners benefit from private residence relief, which exempts the sale of their primary residence from capital gains tax (CGT). Reeves is exploring a plan to remove this exemption for homes above a threshold—rumoured at around £1.5 million.
- Higher-rate taxpayers could face a 24% CGT bill on their gains.
- Basic-rate taxpayers would pay 18%.
- A homeowner selling a £1.5m property might face a tax bill close to £200,000.
For the government, such a measure could raise tens of billions. But for households—especially pensioners looking to downsize—the impact could be profound.
Alternative Options
The Treasury is also examining two other approaches:
- Annual levy on high-value homes – similar to proposals once floated by the Liberal Democrats.
- Council tax reform – modernising a system still pegged to 1991 values by adding new bands or adjusting multipliers for higher-value properties.
Both options face practical and political hurdles. Council tax reform would be administratively complex and politically risky. An annual levy would be easier to implement but risks destabilising the property market.
Likely Impact on the Housing Market
Property experts have sounded the alarm:
- Behavioural distortions – Owners may simply sit tight rather than sell, restricting supply.
- Downsizing deterrent – Pensioners could feel “trapped” in larger homes.
- Market slowdown – Fewer transactions would reduce Treasury revenues and squeeze mobility for families and first-time buyers.
- Equity erosion – In areas like central London, where house prices have stagnated or fallen, there may be little “gain” left to tax.
Even property commentators such as Kirstie Allsopp have warned that talk of mansion taxes risks destabilising confidence in the market before any legislation even arrives.
Why “Fairness” Is the Watchword
Reeves has made fairness her guiding principle. The current council tax system allows a £1m property to pay only double the rate of an £80,000 home. Critics call it regressive, out of date, and overdue for reform.
For Labour, a targeted tax on high-value homes offers a politically defensible way to raise revenue without breaking promises not to tax “working people.” But whether the policy raises what is needed—or simply freezes market movement—remains to be seen.
What This Means for You
If you own—or plan to inherit—a high-value property, these proposals could have major implications for your wealth, your retirement strategy, and even your children’s financial future.
For many, this is a moment to pause and ask:
- Should I review my housing and downsizing plans?
- Do I need to adjust my retirement income strategy?
- What does this mean for estate planning and inheritance tax exposure?
These are not questions to face alone. A Financial Life Coach can help you explore the options, model different outcomes, and design a plan that protects your lifestyle while navigating a shifting tax landscape.
Closing Reflection
History tells us the mansion tax debate is politically explosive and economically delicate. But this time, with a £50bn gap to fill, the conversation may not go away. Whether the Chancellor opts for capital gains reform, a new levy, or council tax bands, the decisions made this October will ripple through families, markets, and communities for decades.
Now is the time to get clarity. If you are impacted, engaging with a Financial Life Coach could be one of the smartest steps you take before the Budget lands.
At times of uncertainty, the right guidance makes all the difference. A Financial Life Coach helps you cut through the noise, understand the implications for your unique situation, and build a plan that protects your future. Don’t wait for the Budget to decide your fate—take control today and explore your options with clarity and confidence.
Academy of Life Planning 