Investment fraud remains a serious problem, with millions of pounds lost to fraudsters every year. In the first half of 2024 alone, £56.4 million was stolen, despite a 29% drop in the number of investment scams compared to last year. While some progress has been made, the truth is, we’re not moving fast enough. The solution? We need a clear separation between financial advice and product sales. It’s time to build a wall between the two and stamp out the root cause of fraud for good.
At present, many financial advisers are incentivised to sell products – investments, insurance, or other financial instruments – because their income depends on commissions or fees tied to those sales. This creates a conflict of interest, where advice is too often shaped by the need to push a product rather than genuinely serving the client’s best interests. It’s this conflict that opens the door for fraud. Unscrupulous individuals can exploit the system, leading to cases where clients are misled, pressured, or outright defrauded.
Building a wall between advice and product sales would remove this conflict. By ensuring that advice is independent, objective, and free from product-driven incentives, the incentive for fraud disappears. Financial advisers could focus on doing what they’re supposed to do—helping clients plan for the future, make informed decisions, and achieve their life goals—without the pressure of selling anything. This shift would immediately boost market integrity and restore trust in the financial services industry.
In fact, the recent drop in the number of fraud cases, as reported by UK Finance, may reflect increased caution from individuals wary of parting with their money in a volatile economic climate. People are becoming more aware of the risks, especially with rising costs of living. Yet despite this, the actual amount of money lost to fraud has only fallen by 1%, which tells us the problem is still substantial. Imagine how much more could be saved, and how many more lives could be protected, if advice and product sales were fully separated?
When we look at the success of new measures like the APP (Authorised Push Payment) reimbursement rules, it’s clear that financial services are moving in the right direction. But prevention is always better than cure. Reimbursement is essential, but it doesn’t undo the damage or prevent fraud in the first place. A proactive solution is to campaign for a clear division between those offering financial advice and those selling financial products.
The benefits are undeniable. Clients would receive unbiased advice that truly reflects their needs and long-term goals. Advisers would be able to focus entirely on their role as trusted guides, without the distraction of sales targets. And ultimately, we’d see a dramatic reduction in fraud cases and the heartache they cause.
It’s time we took a stand. Let’s campaign together to build a wall between financial advice and product sales. By doing so, we can protect consumers, eliminate fraud incentives, and restore confidence in the financial industry. After all, financial advice should be about securing people’s futures, not making a quick profit.
Let’s act now, before more hard-earned money is lost to this preventable crime. Together, we can make a difference and build a safer, more transparent financial future for all.
If you’d like to discuss how independent financial advice can help you achieve your goals, free from sales-driven motives, reach out to us today. We’re here to help you make informed, confident decisions about your future.
Questions & Answers
Q: Why is separating advice from product sales so important?
A: Separating advice from product sales removes the conflict of interest that can arise when financial advisers are incentivised to sell certain products. This means the advice you receive is truly in your best interest, free from the pressure of pushing a product. With this separation, advisers can focus solely on guiding you towards your financial goals, not on meeting sales targets. This shift will help reduce fraud, ensure transparency, and restore trust in the financial industry.
Q: How does separating advice from sales help reduce fraud?
A: Fraud often occurs when the person giving advice is motivated by commissions or bonuses tied to the products they’re selling. By creating a clear wall between advice and product sales, the incentive for fraud is removed. Advisers will no longer have a reason to push products that don’t suit your needs, reducing the chances of being misled or defrauded. This leads to a fairer, safer financial environment for everyone.
Q: Weren’t commissions meant to be banned under the Retail Distribution Review (RDR) in the UK?
A: Yes, under the RDR, commissions were banned in an effort to improve transparency and reduce conflicts of interest. However, while the term “commission” disappeared, the same percentage-based fees were simply renamed as “initial” or “ongoing advice charges.” In fact, in many cases, adviser charges actually increased. For example, ongoing trail commission of 0.5% was often replaced by ongoing adviser charges of 1% per year.
It’s also important to note that the changes only applied to regulated retail investments in the UK. Unregulated investments remained unaffected, and international sales were not subject to the same rules. So, while the RDR aimed to improve transparency, there’s still room for confusion, especially in areas not covered by these regulations.
This is why separating advice from product sales is more crucial than ever. By doing so, we can ensure that advice is truly independent, reducing conflicts of interest and restoring trust in the financial services industry. Together, we can create a more transparent, fair, and secure financial future for everyone.
Q: Won’t this make financial advice more expensive?
A: Actually, separating advice from product sales could make it more cost-effective in the long run. While you might pay a fee upfront for independent advice, you’ll benefit from receiving guidance that is tailored to your true needs, not based on products that pay commissions. In the end, this can save you from costly mistakes or being tied to unsuitable investments. It’s a small price to pay for peace of mind and the confidence that your financial future is secure.
Q: How can I be sure my financial adviser isn’t selling me something for their own benefit?
A: A great way to ensure this is by working with an adviser who provides independent, fee-based advice and isn’t paid by product sales. These advisers are committed to helping you make decisions based on your goals and situation, not on what earns them a commission. Always ask how your adviser is compensated, and seek transparency in their services. With a clear separation between advice and sales, you can trust that the guidance you’re receiving is genuinely in your best interest.
Q: What can I do to protect myself from investment fraud?
A: The first step is to work with a financial adviser who doesn’t have a vested interest in selling products. Seek independent, unbiased advice from someone who is focused on your financial well-being rather than on product sales. Be cautious of “too good to be true” offers and always verify the legitimacy of any investment opportunities. Asking the right questions and staying informed can go a long way in protecting yourself from fraud. See: How to Protect Yourself from Scams: Staying One Step Ahead of Fraudsters.
Q: How can I support the campaign to separate advice from product sales?
A: You can support the campaign by spreading awareness and choosing to work with advisers who offer independent, fee-based advice. Educate others on the importance of separating advice from sales to reduce fraud and conflict of interest. The more people demand this clear distinction, the quicker the industry will shift towards a safer, more transparent approach. Together, we can make financial advice a trustworthy space for everyone.
Q: What are the benefits of working with an adviser who doesn’t sell products?
A: The main benefit is peace of mind. When your adviser isn’t tied to product sales, their advice is based purely on your best interests. You’ll receive unbiased guidance that helps you reach your financial goals without the influence of sales commissions. This ensures greater transparency and trust in the process, making your financial planning journey smoother and more secure.
Q: Can separating advice and sales really make a difference in the fight against fraud?
A: Absolutely. Fraud thrives when there are conflicts of interest, and many financial scams occur because of the blurred lines between advice and sales. By removing the financial incentives that drive product-pushing behaviour, we can eliminate one of the major factors that lead to fraud. Separating advice from sales is a proactive step towards a safer, more trustworthy financial landscape.
These Q&As are designed to educate, motivate, and reassure readers while highlighting the benefits of separating financial advice from product sales. They aim to build trust and encourage thoughtful action toward safer financial practices.
Academy of Life Planning 