By Steve Conley, Academy of Life Planning
“When systems are built on inertia, they collapse under disengagement.”
New data released under a Freedom of Information request has revealed a shocking truth:
Less than one-third of Nest’s 13.7 million members are paying into their pensions.
That means nearly 10 million workers—almost half the UK workforce—have abandoned their pension pots.
After 13 years of automatic enrolment (AE), this isn’t a story of success. It’s the story of a system that mistook participation for empowerment, and passivity for trust.
From coverage to complacency
When AE launched in October 2012, it was hailed as a social breakthrough: millions finally saving for retirement.
But auto-enrolment’s greatest strength—its reliance on inertia—has become its fatal flaw.
People were encouraged to “set and forget.”
Now they’ve simply forgotten.
- 412,000 Nest members have never contributed a penny.
- Fewer than 2% have ever increased their contributions.
- The average pot is just ÂŁ4,000, barely enough for one year of basic living costs in retirement.
This isn’t financial inclusion—it’s financial sedation.
A structural failure, not a behavioural one
Politicians and providers blame “low engagement.”
But workers aren’t disengaged because they’re lazy; they’re disengaged because the system isn’t built for them.
Auto-enrolment designed savers as passengers, not participants.
It created millions of fragmented, low-value pots—each quietly eroded by fees and neglect.
This fragmentation is a form of hidden wealth leakage, a silent extraction that benefits layers of intermediaries more than investors.
We don’t have a pension participation crisis.
We have a structural trust crisis.
Why trust matters more than education
Financial education campaigns won’t fix this.
You can’t educate people into trusting a system that has repeatedly failed them.
Workers disengage because:
- They can’t see or control their money.
- The system feels opaque, paternalistic, and impersonal.
- “Experts” speak in jargon and serve institutions before individuals.
Until we build pensions that are structurally trustworthy—transparent, portable, product-free, and life-centred—engagement will never follow.
From passive saving to active planning
The next era of reform must go beyond auto-enrolment.
We need auto-empowerment—systems that activate human capital, not just financial capital.
At the Academy of Life Planning, we teach individuals to become their own financial planners through our Planning My Life framework.
We help people reconnect money to meaning—so their financial architecture serves their life plan, not the other way around.
Because when citizens plan their lives consciously, they invest with purpose, save with confidence, and retire with dignity.
A call to policymakers
The Nest data should be a wake-up call.
If we want a nation ready for retirement, we must replace the “growth agenda” of capital accumulation with a trust agenda of empowerment.
That means:
- Open data and portable lifetime accounts.
- Transparent, low-cost planning tools for all.
- A national focus on human capital development.
- Genuine financial capability—rooted in purpose, not products.
Only then will auto-enrolment evolve from a mass participation scheme into a movement of active, conscious savers.
Trust delivers engagement. Engagement delivers prosperity.
It’s time to stop nudging and start empowering.
Join us at the Academy of Life Planning.
Let’s raise capability and integrity — together.
Because only when products and services are structurally trustworthy can consumers truly be free.
Get SAFE Exists to Support After Financial Exploitation
Get SAFE (Support After Financial Exploitation) is building a national lifeline for victims — providing free emotional recovery, life-planning, and justice support through our:
- Fellowship:Â peer-to-peer recovery and community.
- Witnessing Service:Â trauma-informed advocacy for those seeking redress.
- Citizen Investigator Training:Â empowering survivors to uncover truth and pursue justice.
Our Goal: Raise ÂŁ20,000 to Rebuild Lives
Your contribution will help us:
Register Get SAFE as a charity (CIO)
Build our website, CRM, and outreach platform
Fund our first year of free recovery and justice programmes
Every ÂŁ50 Changes a Life
Each £50 donation funds a bursary for one survivor — giving them access to the tools, training, and community that restore confidence, purpose, and hope.
This Isn’t Just a Fundraiser — It’s a Movement
We’re reclaiming fairness and rebuilding trust, one life at a time.
Support the Crowdfunder today
Be part of the movement to rebuild lives and restore justice.
Academy of Life Planning 