The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) matrix is a strategic tool used to assess the product life cycle and helps businesses understand their product portfolio dynamics. Within this matrix, a “Cash Cow” is a product or service that generates substantial revenue with low investment, often in a mature market. However, even Cash Cows can transition into “Dogs,” which are characterised by low growth and low market share. Identifying the early indicators of this transition is crucial for maintaining strategic oversight and adapting business models accordingly.
Early Indicators of a Cash Cow Turning into a Dog
- Leveling Off in Headcounts and Revenues: A significant early sign that a Cash Cow is turning into a Dog is the stagnation or decline in headcounts and revenues. In mature markets, a steady or increasing headcount often correlates with sustained business activity and growth. Conversely, a decline may indicate diminishing demand or market saturation.
- Revenue Decline: A continuous decline in revenue is a critical indicator. It may suggest that the market is becoming saturated, competition is intensifying, or consumer preferences are shifting. For Cash Cows, even a slight dip in revenue can signal a transition phase where the product or service is losing its competitive edge.
- Decreased Market Share: A drop in market share is another telltale sign. This could result from emerging competitors, changes in consumer behaviour, or innovation in the market that the current product or service fails to match.
- Reduced Profit Margins: Diminished profit margins due to increased costs or reduced pricing power can indicate that the product or service is no longer as valuable in the marketplace. This often precedes the transition from Cash Cow to Dog.
- Shift from Commission to Fee-based Revenue: A significant shift in the revenue model, such as a move from commission-based to fee-based income, can indicate changing industry dynamics. This might reflect a broader trend where traditional revenue sources are under pressure.
Application to the Financial Advice Industry
Recent data from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) highlights several concerning trends in the financial advice industry that may suggest a transition from Cash Cow to Dog for some firms.
- Slight Decline in Adviser Numbers: The number of retail investment advisers decreased to 37,136 in 2023 from 37,381 in 2022. Although the drop is slight, it suggests a potential plateau or decline in the workforce, often a precursor to reduced business activity.
- Revenue Dip: The reported revenue from retail investment intermediation fell by 3 percent to £5.3bn in 2023 from £5.5bn in 2022. A consistent revenue decline is a strong indicator of a Cash Cow transitioning into a Dog, reflecting possible market saturation or increased competition.
- Reduction in Commission-based Revenue: The share of retail investment revenue from commission decreased from 13 percent in 2022 to 12 percent in 2023. Since 2016, commission-based revenue has seen a significant drop of £187mn. This shift may point to changing consumer preferences and regulatory pressures affecting traditional revenue streams.
- Fee and Charge-based Revenue Decline: Revenue from fees and charges also fell to £4.6bn in 2023 from £4.7bn in 2022, indicating a broader trend of declining profitability within the sector.
- Mortgage Broking and Insurance Distribution Trends: While the mortgage broking sector saw a 13 percent revenue decline, non-investment insurance distribution experienced a 16 percent rise. The contrasting trends within related financial sectors highlight shifting market dynamics and areas of opportunity versus decline.
Conclusion
The financial advice industry exhibits several early signs of transitioning from Cash Cow to Dog, notably in declining adviser numbers and revenues. These trends suggest that firms must adapt to changing market conditions, possibly through innovation, diversification, and adjusting business models to sustain profitability. Continuous monitoring of these indicators can help industry players anticipate shifts and strategically navigate the evolving landscape.
Academy of Life Planning 